...

How to Compare Landed Costs for Phone Case Orders

Share:

Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents
    Scroll to Top

    To compare phone case landed cost, price every supplier quote against the same order, the same U.S. delivery point, the same shipment assumptions and the same delivery term. Then add only the transport, import and delivery charges you will pay that each quote leaves out. Compare the finished order totals, then divide each total by the same number of saleable cases.

    A low factory unit price doesn’t tell you what it costs to get the cases to your door. Duties and taxes also depend on your own order and importer details, so confirm them for your situation instead of assuming a generic rate.

    Set One Comparable Order and Delivery Scenario

    Write down one scenario first and send it to every supplier. If one quote covers a different case, quantity or destination, any price gap could come from the order itself and not from the supplier’s pricing. Keep these items the same:

    Warehouse worker unpacking a carton of phone cases in assorted colors onto a receiving table
    • Case configuration: phone model and fit, material, finish, customization method, artwork and packaging.
    • Order quantity: the same unit count for each quote, plus how the supplier handles defects or overage.
    • Currency basis: one currency, with quote validity dates and any exchange-rate conditions stated.
    • U.S. delivery point: the exact receiving address, warehouse or port where your cost comparison ends.
    • Shipment assumptions: the same shipping mode and route, so air and ocean quotes don’t get mixed.
    • Delivery term: the named term, named place and edition for each quote.
    • Written itemization: a list of what each price includes, what it excludes and what it leaves unknown.

    Record the replies in a simple worksheet before you do any math:

    Supplier Quoted amount and currency Included / excluded / unknown costs
    Supplier A
    Supplier B
    Supplier C

    Leave a cell blank until the supplier answers in writing. A blank cell is a question to follow up on. It doesn’t mean the cost is zero.

    Read Quote Inclusions Against the Delivery Term

    The delivery term tells you where each quote stops, but it doesn’t replace the itemized list. The International Trade Administration explains that Incoterms define delivery responsibilities between seller and buyer, including who handles shipping, insurance and tariffs. The same guidance says to clearly state which Incoterms edition applies, such as Incoterms 2010 or Incoterms 2020.

    For your comparison, this means two quotes with different term labels probably stop at different points. One may end before international freight and another may include more of the trip, so their prices aren’t directly comparable yet. Ask each supplier to put the exact term, named place and edition on the quote.

    Then check that term against the supplier’s written list of what’s included, because the label alone doesn’t show everything a specific quote covers. Ask each supplier this: “Which transport, insurance, import, handling and final-delivery charges are included in this price, and which will be billed separately?” Use the written answer to fill in your worksheet.

    Add Buyer-Payable Costs Through the U.S. Delivery Point

    Your order total is the supplier price plus every remaining charge you pay to get the goods to your chosen delivery point. Here’s the formula:

    Buyer-payable total = quoted goods and customization costs + buyer-paid transport, import, handling and final-delivery charges not already in the quote

    Build it line by line:

    1. Start with the supplier price. Keep goods, customization, setup and packaging charges visible as the supplier part of the total.
    2. Add transport you pay for. Include freight, insurance and delivery after arrival only when you pay them and the quote doesn’t already cover them.
    3. Add import and handling charges that apply. Include duties, taxes, fees, broker or handling charges only when they apply to the order and aren’t already bundled in the quote.
    4. Add final delivery. Include any trucking or delivery to your receiving address if your comparison ends there and no one else is covering it.
    5. Mark unknowns. Label any unconfirmed amount as pending. Don’t plug in a guessed rate, and don’t quietly treat it as zero.
    6. Check for double-counting. Compare every added line with the supplier’s list of included costs, so a bundled charge never gets counted twice.
    Flowchart adding buyer-paid costs without double counting, and marking unconfirmed amounts as pending

    When every line that applies is confirmed, you have a confirmed total. If one or more lines are still pending, call it a provisional estimate and keep the pending lines separate. That way you can see how much of the comparison is still uncertain.

    Compare the Order Total and Per-Saleable-Case Cost

    Compare two numbers for each quote: the buyer-payable order total and the landed cost per saleable case. The order total tells you how much cash the purchase takes. The per-case figure tells you what each sellable unit really costs you.

    Landed cost per saleable case = buyer-payable total through the chosen delivery point ÷ agreed saleable-case count

    Use the same saleable-case count for every quote, based on your order scenario. If one quote assumes a different quantity, ask for a new quote first. Dividing unlike quantities only hides the difference.

    This step shows why a low factory price can mislead you. A supplier with a cheaper unit price may leave freight, insurance or delivery off the quote, while a higher quote may already include them. Once both totals reach the same delivery point, the ranking can stay the same or flip.

    If import charges or other lines are still pending, compare the confirmed subtotals side by side and list the pending amounts separately for each supplier. Don’t pick a winner until both quotes reach the same delivery point with the same level of confirmation.

    Confirm Import Charges for the Actual Order

    Plan for import charges, but don’t guess their amounts. Duties, taxes and fees depend on your actual goods and your situation as the importer. A rate you saw for a different product or order doesn’t settle the question.

    Responsibility also stays with you. U.S. Customs and Border Protection states that even when you use a customs broker, the importer of record remains responsible for accurate entry documents and all applicable duties, taxes and fees. A supplier’s estimate or a broker’s quote can help you plan, but neither one takes that responsibility off you.

    Keep import charges as their own line for each quote and mark them pending until they’re confirmed for your order. Once they’re confirmed, update the totals and the per-case cost, and drop the provisional label.

    FAQs

    Is landed cost the same as customs value?

    No. CBP’s customs-value guidance shows that customs value is not the same as a delivery budget. It lists specific additions to the price, which count only when they aren’t already included, and it leaves international freight and insurance out of transaction value. Your landed-cost worksheet is for budgeting, not for working out customs value.

    Can I compare quotes that use different delivery terms?

    Yes, but only after you bring them to the same point. Add the charges you’d pay under each quote until both reach the same U.S. delivery point. Then compare the totals.

    What should I do if a supplier can’t tell me what is included?

    Treat the missing items as unknown and ask for a written breakdown. Until you have it, call that quote’s total provisional and don’t rank it against fully itemized quotes.

    Can you help us put our quote on a matching basis?

    Yes. Send us your case specification, quantity, U.S. delivery point and preferred delivery term through our store homepage. We’ll tell you in writing what our quote includes and what it leaves out.

    CONTACT US